BlockchainCrypto Coin Show News Team·October 30, 2026·5 min read
Israel’s Supreme Court rejected a defendant’s “code is law” defense and extradited a Nomad bridge exploiter to face U.S. charges. The ruling creates tension with inconsistent U.S. verdicts that have acquitted or deadlocked on similar exploitation cases, leaving institutional investors and platform operators uncertain which jurisdiction will ultimately define the legal boundary between permitted code execution and fraud.
- Alexander Block, an Israeli-Russian citizen, extradited Thursday after Israel’s Supreme Court ruled exploiting a software flaw is criminal even when code permits it.
- Block allegedly used Nomad’s June 2022 bug to withdraw $2.8 million in tokens without depositing backing assets, then moved proceeds between wallets to obscure their origin.
- U.S. courts have reached opposite conclusions: Judge Arun Subramanian vacated Avraham Eisenberg’s Mango Markets convictions in May 2025, but a jury convicted Jonathan Spalletta of Uranium Finance hacking in October.
Israel handed Alexander Block to U.S. prosecutors on Thursday after its Supreme Court rejected his argument that exploiting a software flaw counts as legal conduct if the code technically permits it. Block, an Israeli-Russian citizen formerly known as Alexander Gurevich, now faces eight federal counts for allegedly stealing $2.8 million from Nomad, a cryptocurrency bridge protocol that allowed users to move assets between blockchains by locking tokens on one chain and releasing equivalent amounts on another. The extradition follows a June 2022 software update to Nomad’s smart contracts that created a critical vulnerability: Block could withdraw tokens without depositing the backing assets required by the system’s design. Supreme Court President Isaac Amit denied Block’s final appeal request on Thursday, clearing the way for his transfer to U.S. authorities, who had requested extradition in December 2024.
Israeli Court Holds Deliberate Bug Exploitation Is Criminal Despite Code Permission
Block’s legal strategy rested on two claims that the Israeli Supreme Court categorically rejected. First, he argued that because Nomad’s automated system technically allowed his transactions through its functions, the conduct could not constitute a crime. Second, he contended that the public blockchain record of his wallet transfers revealed his identity and disproved money-laundering intent.
The court held that deliberately exploiting a programming flaw qualifies as unlawful computer intrusion under Israeli law regardless of whether the software technically permits the action.
It also ruled that publicly visible transactions do not identify wallet controllers or rule out efforts to conceal the source of funds, a finding with direct implications for the “code is law” defense increasingly cited in U.S. crypto cases.
Block was arrested at Ben-Gurion Airport in May 2025 carrying a newly issued passport under his adopted surname, attempting to board a flight to Russia days after changing his legal name from Gurevich to Block.
Nomad’s $186 Million Drain Exposed Industry Vulnerability to Mass Exploitation
Prosecutors allege that on August 1, 2022, Block conducted six test transfers to probe Nomad’s vulnerability before executing four larger withdrawals totaling $2.8 million. He then converted the tokens into other cryptocurrencies and moved them across multiple wallets to obscure their origin, conduct the U.S. Northern District of California indicted in August 2023.
His actions exposed the flaw to the broader user base. Within days, other users rushed to drain a Nomad wallet containing more than $186 million, nearly the entire bridge’s liquidity, in what became a race-to-bottom event that wiped out the platform’s reserve capital and exposed the cascade risks inherent in bridges that consolidate assets across multiple blockchains.
U.S. Judges Split on Whether Smart Contract Permissions Block Fraud Prosecution
The Israeli court’s rejection of “code is law” stands in sharp contrast to divergent outcomes in American federal courts. In May 2025, U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian threw out the fraud convictions of Avraham Eisenberg, who had exploited Mango Markets, a decentralized exchange, by manipulating its price oracle, borrowing over $100 million against inflated collateral, and then dumping the tokens to crash the price. Judge Subramanian found that Mango Markets had no terms of service, no prohibition against manipulation, and no requirement that loans be repaid, meaning Eisenberg made no materially false statement sufficient to constitute wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1343. The ruling turned partly on improper venue, the prosecution had argued that vendor monitoring in Manhattan and a user withdrawal attempt in Poughkeepsie established jurisdiction in New York, which the court rejected as insufficient under constitutional venue doctrine.
However, in November 2025, a Manhattan jury locked in a stalemate over brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, charged with a $25 million Ethereum arbitrage scheme. The judge declared a mistrial, and prosecutors asked to retry them in early 2026. Then on October 7, a Manhattan jury convicted Jonathan Spalletta of Uranium Finance hacking on computer-fraud and money-laundering counts tied to two 2021 attacks that cost the exchange more than $50 million. That swift guilty verdict, reached in under two hours, suggests some juries remain willing to distinguish between permitted code execution and intentional theft disguised as a technical exploit.
The split decisions leave the legal standard undefined: no U.S. appellate court has yet ruled whether “code is law” can ever shield a defendant from fraud prosecution, or whether the question turns on jurisdiction, written terms of service, materiality of misrepresentation, or intent.
Institutional Operators Face Conflicting Standards Across Jurisdictions
Block’s extradition and the Israeli Supreme Court’s ruling impose a new compliance burden on platforms and their users. If American courts follow the Israeli precedent, platforms will need to document not just what code permits but what conduct they explicitly prohibit, and to prosecute exploitation of known bugs as theft even if the smart contract technically allows the transaction.
Conversely, if U.S. courts continue to require proof of material misrepresentation (the Eisenberg standard) or venue issues block prosecution, platforms in America could face pressure to shore up their terms of service and user agreements to define prohibited behavior with precision.
The ruling also raises the stakes for bridge protocols, which consolidate liquidity and create single points of failure; operators will likely face increased liability if they leave known flaws unpatched or fail to document exploit vectors as violations of their terms.
The CCS read. Block’s extradition signals that foreign courts will criminalize exploitation regardless of code permission, but American juries have not reached consensus. Institutional platforms cannot rely on “code is law” to survive prosecution in Israel, EU or UK courts; they need explicit terms of service, rapid patching protocols, and clear documentation of what users may not do. The open question is whether U.S. federal appellate courts will adopt the Israeli logic or continue the venue and materiality defenses that freed Eisenberg.
Block faces an indictment filed in the Northern District of California in August 2023. His case will likely proceed through discovery and plea negotiations before any trial, giving U.S. prosecutors and courts a chance to rule on whether Israeli precedent influences American enforcement. Any Peraire-Bueno retrial and any appellate decisions in Eisenberg’s case will be closely watched by platforms seeking clarity on what contractual language and enforcement mechanisms can prevent exploitation charges from sticking.
Get this in your inboxThe Crypto Coin Show newsletter covers the policy and market moves institutional crypto investors are pricing in.
Subscribe