Judge dismisses all charges against Milei in LIBRA meme coin collapse
An Argentine federal judge has dismissed all charges against President Javier Milei and ten others in the LIBRA meme coin collapse, ruling that a token’s promotion, price surge, and crash do not constitute fraud without proof of deception, a decision that eliminates the prosecution’s sole remaining accuser and leaves excluded plaintiffs with only a narrow appeal window.
- Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi found no criminal deception in LIBRA’s promotion, despite the token rising to $4.5 billion in market value then falling 95% within hours on February 14, 2025.
- Eight team wallets tied to the project cashed out $107 million before the collapse, but the court ruled economic loss alone does not prove fraud.
- The prosecutor’s withdrawal as sole accuser left no party to oppose dismissal, prompting the judge to archive the case; excluded plaintiffs now seek Federal Cassation Court review to reinstate their standing.
- $4.5B Peak market value of LIBRA token before 95% crash within hours
- $107M Amount withdrawn by eight team wallets during price spike
- 60 Pages in Judge Martínez de Giorgi’s ruling on the case dismissal
Federal Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi has cleared President Javier Milei and ten co-defendants in the LIBRA scandal, ruling that the meme coin’s promotion by Milei, its astronomical rise to $4.5 billion in market capitalization, and subsequent 95% collapse within hours do not constitute fraud under Argentine law. The 60-page ruling, issued following a recommendation by Prosecutor Eduardo Taiano, found no criminally relevant deception in the token’s marketing or the investors’ losses. Crucially, none of the eleven defendants, including Milei’s sister Karina, developers Hayden Davis and Julian Peh, and lobbyist Mauricio Novelli, were ever formally questioned as suspects before dismissal.
Judge rejects deception standard, citing Milei’s personal account status
In his core holding, Martínez de Giorgi wrote that a promotion, a rally, and a crash do not prove fraud alone, and that economic loss is not automatically a crime. He emphasized that Milei had posted his LIBRA endorsement from his personal X account rather than from the official presidential account, and that no state resources funded the token’s development. This distinction, between Javier Milei the private citizen and the President of Argentina, proved central to the dismissal. The judge also noted that investigators could not establish a link between a note on Novelli’s phone referencing $5 million in payments and any criminal scheme. The only documented connection between Karina Milei and Hayden Davis was a single Casa Rosada entry authorization from July 2024.
Prosecutor’s withdrawal ends all formal opposition to dismissal
The case’s trajectory reveals how institutional structure shaped its outcome. For months, a coalition of private attorneys representing victimized investors maintained the prosecution, filing complaints and securing a preventive seizure of Davis’s assets. The judge excluded all private plaintiffs from the case.
His wife was later appointed to a federal court in July via a decree that Milei signed, an appointment critics seized on as a potential conflict of interest. When Prosecutor Taiano then recommended dismissal, he became the sole remaining accuser.
Under Argentine procedure, once the prosecution withdraws its charge, no other party stands to oppose the judge’s decision, and dismissal becomes procedurally inevitable.
A promotion, a rally, and a crash do not prove fraud alone.
Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi, 60-page ruling on LIBRA case dismissal
On October 23, 2026, Milei responded to the acquittal by declaring that “justice has put things in their proper place,” while also blaming what he termed a political and media operation against his government. Opposition Deputy Maximiliano Ferraro rejected the verdict as “a clear planned judicial operation of cover-up and impunity,” noting that his congressional commission had concluded in November 2025 that Milei provided essential collaboration to the project.
Excluded plaintiffs pursue appeal through higher court
The court has archived the case, but the pathway to reinstatement remains open. Excluded plaintiffs have filed a request with the Federal Cassation Court to restore their status as parties to the proceeding, an action that could theoretically reopen the door to appeal and potentially force a retrial on the merits.
The timing and outcome of this request, along with whether Cassation accepts the argument that the judge’s July removal of private accusers violated procedural fairness, will determine whether the LIBRA dismissal stands as final or represents a temporary clearing that could reverse under appellate review. For now, the case is closed and the defendants formally cleared.
The CCS Read. We see a structural problem: the judge removed every private plaintiff before the prosecutor withdrew, leaving no one to contest dismissal. That sequence made the verdict inevitable rather than reasoned. For institutional investors watching regulatory appetite for meme coin promotion by sitting heads of state, this Argentine ruling offers no clarity on whether such conduct will face consequences elsewhere, the decision hinges on technicalities of standing and account ownership rather than on the substance of who benefited and who lost.
The Federal Cassation Court’s decision on whether to reinstate excluded plaintiffs remains pending and will determine whether the case can proceed to substantive appeal. Separately, observers should monitor whether other prosecutors or regulators outside Argentina file parallel charges; similar enforcement against figures who promoted fraudulent tokens has succeeded in other jurisdictions where the promotion-crash-withdrawal sequence faced stricter evidentiary standards.