Exchange News

CFTC opens regulated routes for onchain perpetuals as Hyperliquid traders lost $1.11B

Exchange NewsCrypto Coin Show News Team·November 19, 2026·4 min read

The CFTC has opened a regulated pathway for blockchain-based derivatives platforms to serve US retail traders through two routes: securing their own exchange licenses or partnering with licensed operators, both subject to the same anti-money laundering, customer protection and market surveillance standards as traditional exchanges. This framework legitimizes onchain perpetual futures trading in the US but leaves a critical question unresolved: whether fragmented order books across separate US and offshore venues will fragment liquidity and amplify price divergence during volatile swings.

  • Backpack secured three CFTC authorizations (FCM, DCM, DCO) as of November 18, enabling it to operate a fully regulated US derivatives exchange.
  • Intercontinental Exchange partnered with Trade[XYZ] to launch a permissioned US venue for Hyperliquid-based perpetuals, pending regulatory approval.
  • A Stanford-Columbia study found Hyperliquid retail traders lost $1.11 billion from March 2025 to June 2026, while market makers gained $208 million.
  • $1.11B Estimated losses by Hyperliquid retail traders over 15 months, March 2025 to June 2026
  • $650B Trading volume processed on Trade[XYZ]’s HIP-3 perpetual markets to date
  • $61.7T Global crypto-perpetuals trading volume in 2025, with $150 billion in reported liquidations

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig issued a statement on November 16 laying out a regulatory framework for onchain derivatives platforms seeking to serve US retail traders, marking the first formal codification of compliance pathways for blockchain-based market infrastructure. The framework requires all platforms, whether obtaining independent exchange licenses or partnering with licensed operators, to meet identical standards for anti-money laundering, customer protection and fund segregation, market surveillance, financial resources and risk management. This approval comes after the CFTC’s May policy statement opened the door to case-by-case review of perpetual futures contracts, paving the way for Backpack to secure three authorizations in November.

Backpack builds independent US exchange while ICE chooses partnership model

Backpack has taken the direct licensing route, securing its futures commission merchant (FCM), designated contract market (DCM) and derivatives clearing organization (DCO) licenses by November 18.

The platform plans to connect US traders with global liquidity through one consolidated order book, positioning itself as a fully regulated US derivatives exchange operating under CFTC oversight from inception.

Intercontinental Exchange, by contrast, chose partnership with Trade[XYZ] to launch a new US-based trading venue using a permissioned version of Hyperliquid’s HIP-3 technology. The arrangement requires identity verification and operates under separate regulatory oversight, still pending final approval. Billionaire Stan Druckenmiller’s investment in Trade[XYZ] signals substantial Wall Street interest in blockchain-based derivatives infrastructure, though the venture’s regulatory status remains in transition.

Separate US order books risk fragmenting liquidity and amplifying price divergence

ICE’s planned US venue will operate independently from Hyperliquid’s existing global markets, creating a material structural risk. According to Galaxy Research, Trade[XYZ]’s HIP-3 markets have already processed over $650 billion in cumulative trading volume, but the new US-regulated venue must build its own domestic pool of liquidity from the ground up. Fragmented order books have historically struggled during volatile market conditions, particularly over weekends when offshore and US venues operate under different settlement cycles.

Price divergence between venues becomes a hedge fund problem: traders managing exposure to the same contract face basis risk and higher execution costs if they cannot access unified liquidity.

Retail losses on Hyperliquid already exceed $1 billion amid leverage debates

Market data reveals the downside of permitting perpetual futures contracts without resolving leverage limits. A Stanford-Columbia study examining ten Hyperliquid contracts from March 2025 to June 2026 found that retail traders using the platform recorded an estimated $1.11 billion in losses, while market makers captured $208 million in gains and the exchange collected $725 million in fees.

The figures underscore a structural imbalance: trading fees alone accounted for 65 percent of retail losses, while adverse price moves and market maker profitability drove the remainder.

The global picture is starker. Crypto perpetual futures generated $61.7 trillion in trading volume during 2025, accompanied by nearly $150 billion in reported liquidations.

A single day, October 10, 2025, saw $19 billion in liquidations alone, raising questions about whether funding rate mechanisms and margin requirements in the current offshore market provide adequate protection against cascading losses during stress events.

Firms employing novel technologies must satisfy the same regulatory standards as those who utilize traditional market infrastructure, including robust anti-money laundering programs, customer protection and segregation requirements, market surveillance programs, financial resources, risk management policies, and system safeguards.

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, Statement on American Innovation and the Future of Market Infrastructure

CME Group and entities tied to Cboe Global Markets and Citadel Securities have challenged the CFTC’s classification of perpetual contracts as futures rather than swaps in court proceedings. Critics argue that perpetuals, which have no expiry date and use recurring funding payments, pose greater leverage and counterparty risks than traditional futures and warrant stricter regulation.

Selig has pushed back, contending that funding payments function as margin adjustments in conventional futures markets. The legal outcome could reshape oversight of both crypto and equity-linked perpetual contracts across US regulated venues.

Bringing offshore trading onshore under CFTC supervision strengthens investor protections through centralized oversight and segregation rules, but bifurcating global and US order books raises execution costs and basis risk for institutions managing multi-venue exposure.

The CCS read. We see institutional liability shifting: Backpack’s independent license makes it a primary counterparty and custodian of retail deposits, absorbing default risk the offshore model had distributed. ICE’s partnership model delays that risk transfer but fragments liquidity. Neither resolves whether funding rate volatility adequately protects leveraged retail positions during market stress or whether the CFTC’s principles-based framework can accommodate perpetual contracts without explicit leverage caps.

The critical next step is whether the ICE-Trade[XYZ] partnership receives final CFTC approval, and if so, whether the two venues maintain price parity or diverge materially within the first 90 trading days of operation, a measure institutional traders and regulators will watch as a leading indicator of whether segregated order books can function at scale without systemic risk.

Get this in your inboxThe Crypto Coin Show newsletter covers the policy and market moves institutional crypto investors are pricing in.

Subscribe