Key takeaways
- TAU Protocol uses synthetic stablecoins backed by Bitcoin hashrate rather than traditional collateral, achieving capital efficiency below 100 percent collateralization.
- The protocol leverages BTCST hashrate tokens from mining farms to create a credible backing mechanism for synthetic Bitcoin, providing psychological confidence in asset stability.
- TAU Protocol differs from collateral-backed stablecoins like USDC and Tether by using algorithmic stabilization mechanisms instead of bank deposits.
- The initial implementation creates approximately 2,000 synthetic bitcoins backed by a smaller amount of actual bitcoins plus hashrate collateral.
- Tim Swanson views TAU Protocol as a part-time project separate from his primary work in digital currency, with potential for future synthetic assets beyond Bitcoin.
Stabilizing around a synthetic
Ashton Addison: What is TAU Protocol, and what problem is it trying to solve?▶ 00:19
Tim Swanson: Over the last six to twelve months a lot of ideas have been implemented in the stabilization space, including algorithmic stablecoins. This one started with a long article I wrote at the very beginning of the year on collateral-backed stablecoins. I wondered what would happen if, instead of stabilizing around the US dollar or the euro, we stabilized around a synthetic. Several projects have done that successfully, such as Synthetix and Mirror, so I certainly don't have a monopoly on the idea. What I wanted was a capital-efficient stabilization mechanism. Something like Synthetix requires massive overcollateralization: you need seven or eight hundred percent of SNX staked to mint something. I wondered about the opposite. Can you do less than 100 percent and still maintain the value? The idea crystallized in mid-January. I found a group that was already building the back-end infrastructure, unrelated to anything I was doing, and told them what I wanted to build on the public-facing side. They put together an implementation, and it turned on just a couple of days ago, on Friday.
Ashton: Why did you choose bitcoin, and how is the synthetic backed?▶ 01:49
Tim: For this first iteration, I wanted an asset that is easy to identify and that everyone knows about. I chose bitcoin, not because anyone knows me as a big bitcoin bull, but because it's well known. The BTCST team had already figured out how to tokenize hash rate, which creates a form of collateral that acts as a backstop for the synthetic bitcoin. I don't know the exact capital efficiency numbers, but about 2,000 or so synthetic bitcoins will be created, with a smaller amount of actual bitcoin backing them. That's not the most important part, though. What matters is having a credible Schelling point, the point at which the market agrees on what something is worth. Some synthetics maintain a peg with no collateral at all, which is the most extreme version, and I'm not saying that's bad. But getting the market to believe a synthetic is worth what it says is a pretty impressive deal when it's fully or at least partially backed.
What I wanted was a capital-efficient stabilization mechanism.
Hash rate as the backstop
Ashton: Is the synthetic based on hash rate, a bit like investing in bitcoin miners?▶ 04:53
Tim: That's a BTCST-specific question, and I don't work for them. But around November or December last year, five mining farms came together to form an open association called the Standard Hashrate Group. They wanted to take a fixed amount of hardware, create a token that represents it, and let retail people, really any spectrum of people, acquire those tokens and stake them. That's the equivalent of mining. The way they describe the BTCST token is as a way of mining without having to buy the hardware. Since they launched, I think three or four other projects, large pools, have tried something similar on slightly different networks. One did it on Ethereum, and BTCST did it on Binance Smart Chain. That's the back end. It helps stabilize this asset because it creates the psychological awareness that the synthetic is backed by real hash rate, and technically it is. But that's separate. They were already working on it, and I had no involvement.
Not a Tether competitor
Ashton: Is TAU meant to be an alternative to Tether or USDC, for example in a bear market?▶ 07:27
Tim: It's serving something different. USDC and Tether are collateral-backed tokens. In theory, although I believe the New York Attorney General has a different view, there's a set of bank accounts holding customer deposits one-to-one with the tokens issued. So if there are 40 billion Tether out there, there should be 40 billion dollars of deposits across several bank accounts. They're solving a problem I'm not interested in at this stage. I could throw my weight behind a collateral-backed stablecoin, but it's not something I'm particularly keen on. I've worked on digital currency projects at the last couple of companies I've been with, so I'm well aware of that arena. This is my part-time fun job. I have a day job, and the company I work for spearheaded the CBDC movement in 2015. I know the challenges of getting banks and central banks on board, and I don't want to do that in my spare time.
Ashton: Where is the project now, and what is the road map?▶ 09:15
Tim: I hate teasing too much, because I don't want to raise expectations. It's a loose project at this stage and I hope to keep it that way. I'm not trying to turn it into a gigantic full-time deal. For other types of synthetics, I'm looking at lightly regulated areas, because once there's enough traction and enough dollar value stored in these products, the risk grows. A couple of projects have synthetically created Tesla or Apple shares, and I think that's a big no-no. It gives the market the perception that these are Tesla or Apple shares, yet there are no voting rights and no dividends, and you didn't get permission from the companies that issue them. I'm not saying I know what will happen to those projects, but there are less risky areas, particularly in the commodity space. That's all I'll say at this stage.
If I have a couple of projects that actually work live, that's much easier than writing lots of tweets or blog posts.
Baby steps and the education problem
Ashton: What will be the key to these assets becoming as popular as collateralized stablecoins?▶ 11:36
Tim: I'm not sure they'll ever become as popular as collateral-backed stablecoins, for a couple of reasons, but that's not the goal either. If we could build and stabilize one synthetic, that would be a win in my book. Then we find other assets that are low-key on the legal and regulatory front and roll those out, and maybe over time the aggregate value is worth quite a bit. That's not the explicit goal. I want to make sure one works, and then maybe try number two and three. Baby steps right now.
Ashton: Do you expect challenges in building awareness and getting people to use these assets?▶ 12:46
Tim: Yes. It's the education hockey stick right now. A week and a half ago there was a miscommunication on social media, and some people spread an inaccurate, misinformed view of what this project is. I've spent the last ten days pushing back on what it is and isn't, which has been frustrating because I'd rather spend that time on other things, like with my two-year-old daughter. The common quip is 'show, don't tell.' If I have a couple of projects that actually work live, that's much easier than writing lots of tweets or blog posts.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded April 2021.
