Key takeaways
- Dash is a Bitcoin fork focused on payments with one to two second transaction confirmation times, comparable to credit card authorization speeds.
- Dash uniquely distributes block rewards among miners, masternodes, and a proposal system funding developers and business development, unlike Bitcoin's miner-only incentives.
- Dash Core Group proposes gradually shifting approximately ten percent of mining rewards to masternodes over five and a half years to reduce price volatility.
- Masternode operators must hold one thousand Dash as collateral, which sequesters supply and can cause long-term price spikes and drops affecting users.
- The proposal system's fixed ten percent allocation proved inflexible during the 2017-2018 crypto bubble, leading to unused or low-value proposals requiring redesign.
Digital cash built for payments
Ashton Addison: For someone who knows Bitcoin but isn't very technical, what is Dash?▶ 00:00
Ryan Taylor: Dash is a digital currency very similar to Bitcoin. In fact, it's a fork of Bitcoin's codebase, but it's focused on the payments use case, so it's pure digital cash. That means several things: a high degree of scalability, low transaction fees and, probably most importantly, instant confirmation. If you're going to use digital currency as cash, you need to confirm quickly. Transactions on Dash's network take one to two seconds, which is about as fast as a credit card authorization, so it's really useful at the point of sale.
At the end of the day, price spikes and drops are not desirable for users.
Paying for more than mining
Ashton: You saw Bitcoin's limitations early. What drew you to Dash?▶ 01:15
Ryan: Beyond transaction speed, what attracted me was that Dash was being set up to be flexible. A decentralized project needs certain prerequisites to move forward and innovate effectively, and Dash's founder, Evan Duffield, had articulated a vision for that. Dash was the first coin I saw that recognized that more than one activity adds value to the network and should be incentivized. In Bitcoin, 100 percent of transaction fees and new coins go to miners, who secure the network. But you also need developers, legal work, business development, marketing and infrastructure that hosts full copies of the blockchain and relays messages at high speed. None of that is incentivized in Bitcoin's protocol. Dash splits its block reward and transaction fees across three main parties. Miners are the same as in Bitcoin. Masternodes are special servers that keep full copies of the blockchain, relay messages and perform other important services. The third is our proposal system, which covers everything else: developers and teams working on the ground toward adoption. Anyone can put up a proposal, say what they'll do for the network and receive funding. That's how Dash Core Group gets its funding.
Ashton: Much of Bitcoin's development is volunteer work. How does building incentives into the protocol compare?▶ 04:27
Ryan: It aligns incentives better. Take Blockstream, which provides a lot of the developers for Bitcoin. They don't necessarily have the user's best interest in mind, because they have their own solutions to sell to the market and an incentive to keep capacity on Bitcoin's blockchain quite low. You can see how that develops into outright conflicts of interest when outside funding sources dictate the development path.
The proposed economics changes
Ashton: What changes has Dash Core Group proposed to Dash's economics, and how would they improve the system?▶ 05:13
Ryan: The most recent change to Dash's economics was in 2015, when the proposal system was added. Before that, only miners and masternodes were incentivized. It has served us very well, but we've noticed some shortcomings. To upgrade a node to a masternode, you have to prove ownership of 1,000 Dash. As people spin up masternodes, they sequester portions of the supply. That has long-term effects on Dash's ability to act as a store of value, and it can cause the price to spike or drop very quickly. At the end of the day, price spikes and drops are not desirable for users. We've analyzed how masternode operators react to those incentives, and we think we have a solution that smooths those effects out. We're proposing a small shift in the reward structure from miners toward masternodes. It's a little less than 10 percent of the reward, phased in over about five and a half years. It's a very subtle change. It's a gradual one. It should dampen volatility, and masternode operators will collect a higher portion of the reward. Counterintuitively, it also benefits miners in the short term. The new distribution encourages more masternodes, which pulls coins out of circulation to collateralize them. That should have a positive effect on price that more than offsets the reduced rewards to miners. A stronger price also makes the proposal system's funding larger in value. Separately, we're proposing to make the proposal system more flexible. During the 2017 and early 2018 bubble, the fixed 10 percent allocation didn't work well. A lot of it went unused or went to dubious proposals with limited lasting value, which created a 'we'd better spend it or it's wasted' attitude. At the other end, in December 2019 the price fell as low as $39, and the proposal system couldn't even fund basic operations. We were digging into our reserves, and a lot of valuable teams were defunded. We want a system that recognizes 10 percent isn't always the right allocation and lets the network flex above or below it as needed.
It's a very subtle change. It's a gradual one.
The vote and how to get involved
Ashton: Is this effective immediately, or is there a timeline for when the changes would take effect?▶ 11:56
Ryan: First we have to put a formal proposal to the network for a vote. We'll hold some Q&As over the next couple of weeks, both in a video chat and with the community, to make sure the proposals are well understood. Then we'll put a decision proposal to the network, which is a simple yes-or-no vote. There will be separate votes on each change, because one could be implemented without the other. If they pass, they'll be implemented in the protocol. One is far easier to make than the other, so we'll code them in as time permits, but we'll move as quickly as we can. If they pass, we're probably looking at the fall. This is something unique to Dash. Getting a new feature into Bitcoin, or other protocols that rely strictly on miners, is a monumental task that requires a supermajority of something like 80 or 90 percent. With our system, we just vote, and if the supermajority is more like 60 percent in favor and 40 percent against, we can implement it safely. Dash pioneered that voting system, and it has allowed us to make more controversial shifts, or make them more safely, without splitting our network.
Ashton: How can people learn more about the vote and get involved with the Dash community?▶ 14:29
Ryan: We have videos of two presentations, one from our open house in December and one released this past week, both titled 'Improving Dash as a Store of Value.' They're on our YouTube channel. Our website has links to all our social media, including a couple of Discord chat groups, Reddit and Twitter, so follow the project wherever suits you. We're always looking for ways to expand our user base. One example is our gift card program, where you can earn discounts on gift cards if you pay in Dash. We like to bring in people who want to incorporate this into their day-to-day life, not just hold it but actually use it, and use it like it's meant to be used, as currency.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded June 2020.
