Skip to content
MCAP $2.16T ▼-4.82%
BTC $62,439 ▼-3.58%
ETH $1,763 ▼-2.78%
BNB $578.21 ▼-2.51%
XRP $0.963 ▼-0.92%
SOL $72.83 ▼-1.49%
DOGE $0.0582 ▼-2.29%
ADA $0.150 ▼-2.87%
TRX $0.3090 ▲+0.47%
LINK $8.99 ▼-2.86%
AVAX $6.93 ▼-3.68%
HYPE $66.29 ▼-4.27%
DOT $0.710 ▼-3.91%

The CCS Interview

Brickken's Edwin Mata: Security tokens need understanding, not new regulation

Edwin Mata is co-founder of Brickken, a platform that helps companies tokenize securities and bring themselves on-chain. In this conversation, recorded in September 2022, he argues that existing rules already cover security tokens, explains how Brickken works with law firms, and sets out the company's funding and hiring plans as they stood at the time.

Interview by Ashton Addison Recorded September 2022 6 min read
Edwin Mata Brickken
Edwin MataCo-Founder

Key takeaways

  • Security tokenization doesn't require new regulation; companies must comply with existing securities laws and understand blockchain as a technology evolution.
  • Brickken provides a user-friendly dashboard and tools for companies to self-deploy tokenization without requiring blockchain technical knowledge.
  • Tokenization operates in two distinct markets: private markets for early-stage funding and public markets requiring regulated exchanges using DLT technology.
  • The regulatory landscape has evolved through communication between regulators and private companies to clarify that tokens are representations of existing securities.
  • Brickken positions itself as a technology provider rather than an intermediary, broker, or exchange to maintain legal compliance without requiring specific licenses.

Why security tokens don't need new rules

Ashton Addison: Where do security token offerings stand in 2022, and why haven't they taken off as expected?▶ 01:05

Edwin Mata: The regulation itself didn't evolve, but the understanding did. One of the biggest issues was that governing bodies, such as the SEC and the regulators in Spain, France and Germany, feared that blockchain was being used to transact securities. But securities have been around forever. They went from verbal to written to paper to digital, and then suddenly everything is in a token, and people got lost. Over time the space has come to understand how blockchain works and that a token is a mere representation of the security. So you really don't need a new regulation, because the regulation already exists. Proof of that is the upcoming European regulation on utility tokens. Article 2, where it sets out what is being regulated under the license, states that it does not deal with securities. We just need people to understand that this is a new technology, as digital was before. For the past five years there have been ongoing conversations between regulators and private companies like mine. You don't need a new regulation. You just need to comply with what you already have, and not pretend to be something you're not.

Ashton: Can you onboard companies from both the US and Europe, and is there a difference between them?▶ 10:34

Edwin: You can do both, but in securities there is always a part that can't be coded. Registering with the SEC in the United States for a security issuance, for example, is subjective: you have to fill in your white paper, your audits and your forms. I don't know when, or if, that will become possible to automate. So at Brickken we've built an ecosystem of experts, including law firms working with us on tokenization in the United States. We provide the tech as the first layer, and for whatever a specific country's regulation requires that I can't code, we have partners. A US company can pick the law firm that fits its needs, whether federal or state. I've spent the past two years bringing on law firms in various countries. In Spain, for example, you just have to send an email with certain information. But I can't draft that email for you.

You don't need a new regulation. You just need to comply with what you already have, and not pretend to be something you're not.

Tokenizing without the blockchain headache

Ashton: If a company knows little about blockchain, how does Brickken guide it through tokenization?▶ 03:46

Edwin: We come from the SaaS industry, where everything has become a click. The user experience matters, whether for the issuer or the investor, and nobody should need to know that blockchain is involved. If I can make my grandma deploy a token, we're good to go. We tested it with non-technical people, and only when they could do it themselves did we say we had a product. We give companies the technology and a dashboard, and we pack all the pains of issuing a token and managing a crowdfunding into a single solution. We also reinforce that what they're doing is legal. There may be complexities and some uncertainty, but it's still legal. Our approach is that we're not an intermediary, a broker or an exchange. We're a tech provider giving them the tools to deploy everything themselves, which also means I don't need a license.

Ashton: Once securities are tokenized, how are they traded and who can buy them?▶ 07:13

Edwin: Creating those markets needs to be regulated. In Europe they're about to deploy the pilot regime for the first stock markets that can use DLT. A company going mass public goes through an IPO, but all the steps before that are still private markets. So tokenization has two layers. In the private layer, I can go to you and say, Ashton, why don't you invest in my company, and I put you on my cap table. In public markets you buy shares through a broker, so you don't actually hold them; the broker represents you. I'm not against that, but it's a different game, and I don't believe it's decentralized, because there's still a broker. It's just public markets using blockchain to be more optimized and transparent. The private markets are where it becomes truly interesting. You won't have huge order books and market makers, but you can create a private market. P2P markets are legal and you don't need a license, as long as the issuer is AML compliant and accepts that both buyer and seller have done KYC. It's less liquid than a full market.

A small market with room to grow

Ashton: How early is security tokenization, and what signs of growth are you seeing?▶ 12:56

Edwin: We started our journey from an education perspective in 2019. One metric I remember is that last year, in June, the market was around 1 billion. Today I think the number is around 19 billion. That's a pinpoint of how the market is reacting to securities. I come from blockchain, but I also spend time with corporates, institutions and regulators. It's one big ecosystem. I read the news, and banks are building digital asset infrastructure, hiring a lot of people in the tokenization space and connecting with tokenization platforms. I'm talking with banks. If you ask me when we're going to boom, right now we're at the early stage, the propeller part of the spaceship launch. Two years from now I think it's going to be quite interesting for the tokenization space.

Ashton: Brickken recently closed a fundraising round. Where is that capital going?▶ 15:02

Edwin: We did our community round, from a community we'd built before launching our ICO, and raised 2 million through it. We're now in our strategic round, closing some VCs, and then we'll go for two more public rounds. One of my biggest milestones is a grant of 325K from the Spanish government. We told them we're a crypto company doing STOs and that we want to tokenize assets, and they gave it to us. We designed the company as an organism, thinking through all the departments and needs. We finished last year with nine people and are 25 this year. Next year, if we raise the strategic and public rounds, we want to double. We need to be quick. In two years, when a competitor hears that tokenization is booming, there's no space. We're in a bear market, and fundraising in 2023 is going to be complicated for newcomers up against capitalized players. For us, the strategic round is about going for the spaceship. There's no little growth, no medium growth.

If I can make my grandma deploy a token, we're good to go.

Collaboration, regulators and on-chain equity

Ashton: Will blockchain companies need to work together to grow this market, and how are regulators responding?▶ 18:22

Edwin: I completely agree. One thing I like about the blockchain space is that there aren't many competitors. I come from SaaS, where competitors were always trying to kill each other. Here we all grow together. In Spain, for example, there are only about three companies in the tokenization space. There's real collaboration: let's build together. Regulators are also approaching these initiatives. They're subsidizing them and even deploying sandbox environments where private companies can run a project alongside a regulatory body. People see the news and say the government is killing everything, but it's their job to take care of things. Problems happen. Luna happened, and it's teaching us a lot. Regulation needs to happen, and it's super slow, but the first approaches are occurring. The United States is about to deploy a sandbox, which will also be massive.

Ashton: What do you say to companies that ask why they should tokenize their equity?▶ 20:59

Edwin: Bring your equity online and let's see how that happens. Today your equity is a document signed in a cap table, but it's static. There's no movement. Putting it on chain gives life to something and places it in an ecosystem that's already flowing. I'm already looking at DeFi protocols where a share could have value because it's backed by a real asset, and you could perhaps collateralize it, loan it or lend it. Who knows what's going to happen, but I know that shares on paper just sit in a drawer and get forgotten. That's why people raise money every six or 18 months: they don't know how to move that. If you put life into it, maybe everything can change.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded September 2022.

Edwin Mata
Edwin MataEdwin Mata is co-founder of Brickken, a platform focused on security token offerings (STOs). He discusses topics including security tokenization, regulatory compliance for bringing companies on-chain, and how organizations can transition to blockchain-based securities. Full profile →
Share this interviewXLinkedIn
▶ Watching the interview
CCS Insider · free, twice a week

New founder interviews in your inbox

The week's interviews and the key takeaways, twice a week from CCS Insider.

Readers in 160+ countries. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.