Key takeaways
- Minds.com operates as an open-source, privacy-focused social network that doesn't surveil users or require personal information for ad targeting.
- The platform's boost feature allows creators to earn tokens through engagement and spend them to guarantee views, addressing organic reach limitations on major platforms.
- Minds Plus subscription at five dollars monthly generates most revenue and includes revenue sharing where creators earn a portion of subscription fees.
- Ad mining integrates DeFi by rewarding liquidity providers in the Minds-ETH pair with guaranteed advertising impressions alongside token rewards.
- The platform structures rewards in three buckets including engagement rewards, with multipliers based on user activity level to balance accessibility for non-technical users.
A social network built around reach
Ashton Addison: What is Minds, and what problem is it solving?▶ 00:19
Bill Ottman: Minds is an open-source crypto social network. Everything is fully transparent and very privacy-focused. We don't require any personal information, and we certainly don't surveil you to target ads like every major social network does. We're also hyper-focused on monetization for creators, in both crypto and fiat. Everybody's reach is getting strangled on the big tech sites. No matter how many followers you have, you're probably only reaching a couple of percent of them. No one knows what the algorithms are doing, or why crypto channels and different types of speech are getting banned. It seems like they're doing everything backwards, so we're trying to switch that. We're also decentralizing as much as we can.
Ashton: What gives Minds a competitive edge over the big platforms?▶ 01:48
Bill: One unique feature is the reward system for the engagement you receive and your contribution to the network. We built it partly in reaction to the strangling of organic reach on major networks. We first launched a digital currency, before moving to Ethereum, that was just a point system. You earned points for various activities, and one point equalled one view, so you could boost your posts and get more views on your content. That's what creators really want. When you put in all this hard work and a platform takes your audience away from you, that is highly unethical. Now that we've migrated to Ethereum, one token equals a thousand views. You earn tokens, click the Boost button on a post, and one token gets you a thousand views. It's by far one of our most popular features. We have about four million users, and Facebook has billions, but that's sort of irrelevant unless you can reach your own fans. If you're in a crowd of people and no one can hear you, what's the point?
If you're in a crowd of people and no one can hear you, what's the point?
Ads without surveillance
Ashton: Could Minds drift toward the pay-to-reach model of Facebook and other platforms?▶ 04:09
Bill: We're not against promotion, or even necessarily against paying for promotion. What we object to is surveillance-based promotion, which to us is the unethical part. If people want to get tokens and boost with them, and put revenue into the ecosystem like that, that's a plus. We're not against advertising, but we're not going to force-feed ads into your news feed. You'll always have a pure chronological news feed. Every 20 posts or so you might see a boost, and you can turn that off with Minds Plus. Minds Plus is where most of our revenue comes from, at five dollars a month. We do a rev share with it. By subscribing, you get access to an exclusive feed of content from everybody in Minds Plus, and if you post into it, you get a share of our revenue. You're paid in fiat or crypto, depending on how you pay for Minds Plus. The analogy I make is, imagine you could submit a film to Netflix and, if it performed well, they gave you a payout at the end of the month. That's been immensely popular.
Ashton: How does ad mining work?▶ 05:53
Bill: Ad mining is the new ad system we've built. If you provide liquidity to the Minds pool, you get close to free advertising. I won't call it free. Based on your percentage share of the liquidity pool, you get that percentage of the rotation in a fixed spot on the side of the news feed. If you pull out your liquidity, you get all your tokens back, and you also get token rewards for providing it. We wanted to bring in something of tangible value for providing liquidity. I'm not trying to denigrate any liquidity mining project, but there's a lot of nonsense out there where you're just mining for the sake of mining, with no intrinsic value to it. We're giving a sort of guaranteed impression value on top of the token rewards.
Making DeFi usable for ordinary users
Ashton: Is liquidity mining too technical for people who just want a private social platform?▶ 08:13
Bill: Our reward system is broken into three buckets. First, engagement rewards: you earn tokens for getting comments, shares and subscribers, just normal social media things. That's easy for anyone to figure out, and the reward is multiplied depending on how much you contribute to the network. The more active you are, the bigger your multiplier. The other two buckets are holding rewards, just for holding tokens in your on-chain web3 wallet, and liquidity rewards. Those two are a bit more technically challenging, but web3 UX is coming a long way. We did a huge integration with WalletConnect and web3 modals, so a prompt comes up asking whether you want to use MetaMask or Coinbase Wallet or whichever. That's becoming a standard on any web3 site. Yes, you have to set up a wallet, but it's not that hard, it's getting easier, and it's a worthy learning curve to take control of your digital assets.
Ashton: Will people from outside crypto go through the extra steps to get that promotion?▶ 11:19
Bill: We've already had people approach us. In the news feed you'll see a block that says "want to be promoted here?" You hover over it and it explains that you have to provide liquidity, then you click and the Uniswap liquidity modal pops up. We've had totally non-crypto people say, "I want to get in here, show me how," and they were in within 10 minutes. It's new, but it's also a good deal, so I think people are willing to be educated. I feel that's part of our role, and social media is a great place to bring crypto to more people. If you tell people, "Learn this app called MetaMask, it's super easy, and you get value from it, as opposed to having value extracted from you," it's going to take time, but we'll get there.
Ashton: Will Minds go further into DeFi, such as borrowing and lending against pool tokens?▶ 12:25
Bill: I'm totally open to investigating all of the above. This initial incarnation is pretty simple. You verify your address through MetaMask to validate that the address is yours and is associated with those pool tokens. We take the liquidity position endpoint on Uniswap and associate it with your address on Minds, so we can understand your participation in the pool on the back end. Using those pool tokens in other creative ways, I'm totally open to that. It's just one step at a time.
Ashton: Minds has been around for years. Why add DeFi now?▶ 13:33
Bill: We've had the tokens for a couple of years, but it's really only in the last year that Uniswap has exploded. It's an incredible tool, and it makes total sense for us to integrate with it. The reward system has been one of our most popular features, and now we can synergize with that whole world. Before, we were sort of isolated in our own little world. Having the dynamic pricing and everything else that comes from Uniswap is way better for everybody. People are loving it so far.
We're not against advertising, but we're not going to force-feed ads into your news feed.
What comes next for Minds
Ashton: What will be the key factors for mainstream adoption?▶ 14:24
Bill: Right now we're working on a huge integration with the Matrix protocol, a decentralized, end-to-end encrypted messaging protocol. We're doing a major overhaul of our messaging system, which I think is absolutely essential for mainstream adoption. Messenger is where people spend most of their time on social networks, and end-to-end encryption is key too. UX does matter, but integrating crypto and social is key because it brings gamification and financial incentive to social media, which doesn't exist on any major social network. What do you get for using Instagram? It's a nicely designed app, and kudos to their designers, but the whole thing is rotten from the core. They extract value from you and give you very little. Within the next couple of years, not just us but other crypto social alternatives will reach parity in functionality with what people expect. At that point everybody will have to ask themselves why they aren't supplementing their experience with something that actually rewards them. We're also investigating bringing in NFTs, so all the assets connected with your address, not just ERC-20s, can be part of it. And earlier this year we launched a major integration with Arweave, a decentralized content storage network, so you can optionally post to a decentralized content system when you make a post.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded April 2021.
